Questioner: Is flattery considered truth? Does flattery mean to endorse something unnecessarily?
Dadashri: That is not called truth. Nothing is worthy of flattery. Flattery is a tool a person uses to conceal his mistake.
Questioner: Is there an advantage to speaking pleasantly with people?
Dadashri: Yes, it makes them happy.
Questioner: But when people discover later on that they have been lied to, they feel hurt. Some people may talk sweetly while some although they may have harsh speech, are sincere and honest.
Dadashri: What is honest speech? Is it the naked truth? If a boy says to his mother, "Hey you, my father's wife!" Is he not stating the truth? Yet such a statement would offend her. It would hurt her very much. You would call this the naked truth.
What is considered truth? There are four components to truth. Truth should be: beneficial, brief, pleasant and true (heet-mitta-priya-satya). Besides being true (satya), the truth should be pleasant to hear (priya), it should be beneficial (heetkari) and also brief (mitta). Not only should the truth be pleasant, but it must also benefit others and be brief too. I said something beneficial and pleasant to you but kept talking, you would say, 'Sir, please stop now and let me have lunch.' So it also needs to be brief. This is not a radio that can talk continuously. So all four components must be present for it to be the truth. To speak only the naked truth makes it not the truth.
What should a person's speech be like? It should include and combine all four of these components otherwise it becomes false. This principle applies to all speech used in our worldly interaction. Only the Gnani's speech encompasses all the four components. His speech is always for the benefit of others, never for his. The Gnani has absolutely no attachment for his relative self
The highest truth is one where no living being is hurt through the medium of the mind, the speech or the actions. This is the highest of all principles. This is not the real Truth (the Self), but it is the ultimate of all worldly truths.
1) What is satya (truth)? When no living being is hurt through speech, is not hurt through conduct or one does not think any thing bad for the other person; it is the greatest truth. It is the greatest principle! It is not the 'real' truth. It is the ultimate 'worldly truth' (vyavahar satya).
2) Decide in your mind that you want to completely live by the absolute worldly truth (vyavahar satya). The one, who follows the worldly truth, can follow the real truth (nischaya satya).
Book Name: Science of Speech (Page #35 Last Second Paragraph; Entire Page #36)
A. When you pluck a string on a sitar, how many different sounds does it produce? Questioner: Many. Dadashri: Even when you pluck just one string? In the... Read More
A. When we talk about the besmearing properties (lepaimaan bhaavo) of the mind, speech and body, what exactly are they? These properties are inanimate (judha... Read More
A. Speech is inanimate. It is a record. Is the tape not previously recorded when the tape-recorder plays? In the same way, the tape of this speech has already... Read More
A. You think that no one hears you scold your wife at home! Married couples quarrel with each other and use reckless language in the presence of their... Read More
A. Whatever comes your way is a result of your own doing. Settle all your past accounts and do not create any new 'loans'. Questioner: What do you mean by... Read More
A. Questioner: Why do people lie without reason? Dadashri: They do it because of their anger, pride, deceit and greed. They do it because they want to gain... Read More
A. Questioner: Will I not bind karma if I lie? Dadashri: Yes definitely! More than the actual lie, the intent to lie is what binds the karma. To tell a lie... Read More
A. Questioner: When does one attain efficacy and power of speech (vachanbud)? Dadashri: The power of speech arises when one does not use a single word to... Read More
A. Questioner: How can the understanding acquired in this life help improve our speech? Please explain with an example. Dadashri: If someone were to insult... Read More